Hi Lon
Honestly, I don't have any clue why it happens. Is the event free or paid event? Did see logged in while registering?
Maybe you can go to Events Booking -> Configuration, set Reduce Registration Process config option to No and continue monitoring it to see whether the issue could happens again
Or maybe it is because the new event has same alias with old event? Access to Events Booking, then Tools -> Purge URLs to reset URLs...
Honestly, I am unsure why it happens, so please keep monitoring it. Doing two things above might help prevent it, too
Tuan