Hi Mike
No, unfortunately, it is not possible. Right now, when you create menu item to display membership, subscribers will be displayed there (can be filtered by subscription status)
There is not an option for members to choose whether they want to be shown on the list. If you really need it, you can consider hiring us customize the extension for you to support this option. It will cost you 30$
If there are more customers requesting for it, I will consider adding support for it in the future (so far, in few years of Membership Pro life, no one has asked for this option)
Regards,
Tuan