Hello Anne
Yes, it is possible. There are few ways to do that:
1. Create a new Joomla user groups, called Assigned Members for example, it should be child group of Registered group
2. Create a new access level called Assigned Members, only select Assigned Members for this access level
3. Edit that plan, set access level to Assigned Members so that only users who you assign to Assigned Members group can see this plan
4. Then these users can login, see the plan, subscribe for it
The otherway is you adding subscription records for these users manually. Just go to Membership Pro -> Subscriptions to add it
Membership Pro, at this time, is really the best Membership solution for Joomla and I will still work hard to improve it
Regards,
Tuan