Hi Maico
No, it doesn't work like that. In Membership Pro, one subscriber can have different subscription records, each record can have independent data for first name, last name... fields
If you set the config option above to Yes, when a subscriber subscribe for a new plan, (or renew for his existing subscription), Membership Pro will update all other subscription records data (just data of custom fields like first name, last name...) with the data of his last subscription so that the data can be synchronized.
So basically, you mis-understood the meaning of the config option. Hope it is clear to you now
Tuan