Hi Alex
1. The PDF Indexer component allows indexing multiple documents at the same time (infact, all documents you are having) within one index (few clicks)
2. The EDocman indexer plugin allows index one document at a time. The document only indexed when you upload/create it
So :
1. If you haven't created any documents in EDocman before, you can use the build-in EDocman indexder plugin
2. If you have created many docuemnts before, you should use OS PDF Indexer. Otherwise, if you want to use EDocman indexer plugin, you will need to re-upload files for each documents so that these documents can be indexed
Regards,
Tuan