Thanks Tuan
Think its rather complex...
Say you have three plans:
Gold, Silver, Bronze
You have 4 ACY Lists - Gold, Silver, Bronze, All Members
You set up the plan to add to the relevant ACY List AND All Members
If a user renews Silver they clearly should stay in Silver and All Members ACY Lists. So that would sound like a bug. **BUT** If they Upgrade to Gold they should be added to Gold (they are) and stay in All Members lists. But when the Silver expires they loose All Members if it is set to remove them from the list on expiry.
You might recall I wrote a plugin to automatically "fall back" a member who expired to say Bronze from Silver. I had similar issues with it, but I've since modified it to check if the member has any other active subscriptions and if it does it doesn't fall back. For ACY thats not as simple... ...it would not just need to check if they had any other subscriptions, check what ACY groups they should have in those and then only cancel a ACY list membership if they didn't have another valid subscripton...
The immediate reaction may be to say: You don't need All Members - just send the All Members newsletter to Gold, Silver and Bronze. My lists are a bit more complex. If a membership has a junior (child) they get added to the Junior's list so that the Junior section can email all juniors. But we have Adult + 1 Child, Adult + 2 Child Plans and Family Member (2 Adults + up to 8 Children) plus Child Alone. So we are actually adding them to a list called Adult and a List called Junior. So Adult + 1 Child upgrades to Family Member this year they should stay on both groups. I don't really want a list per user plan type because it will be a lot of lists because we have rather a complex variation of plans because there isn't a shopping cart so we have to have every possible combination!
