Hi Michelle
Unfortunately, it is not possible. If you create an event, it will be displayed on Events Category page. If you want to get this feature works well, I think you will have to customize code :
1. Edit the event add/edit screen allows you to choose whether the event will be displayed on category page or not.
2. Edit the events category page and only display the events which are choose to be showed.
If you know programming, you can do that. If not, maybe you can hire someone to customize it for you. If you want to hire us, it will cost you 40$ for this modification .
Tuan